Haha, can you tell I got lazy with trying to line them up all straight?  My floor’s uneven, and these pencils were rolling everywhere, so I said “Screw it!”

Make Up For Ever mini Aqua Eyes in 4L, 23L, 21L and 12L – This was part of this set (which apparently you can still buy?).  I gave 0L to my mom because I have a full size one, and I re-used the tin as a travel sized first aid kit (but I think I left it in Albert’s room in London).  These are nice, but not as creamy as my beloved UD ones.  These colors are also quite dupe-able in my UD stash.  Still, I’ll keep them around.
Verdict: Keep

Cargo Swimmables Eyeliner in Teal (?) – I wrote previously that this is a color dupe for MUFE’s 12L, but despite being called “Swimmables,” it wasn’t particularly waterproof on my lower lash line.  I actually haven’t tried it since then.  I’ll try it again when I get home and decide from there.
Verdict: Maybe

Urban Decay Heavy Metal Glitter Liner in Midnight Cowboy – I think this came as a GWP on urbandecay.com.  I’ve used it a few times.  I should probably give it away.
Verdict: Give Away

Fantasy Makers in Cryptic, Magical and Secrecy – I picked these up during Halloween!  They’re by Wet ‘n’ Wild, and therefore really cheap.  I like layering the green one over Urban Decay’s Flipside liner.  It’s amazeballs.
Verdict: Keep

NYX Liquid Crystal Liner in Crystal Hip – I think that’s what this is called.  It’s not very opaque, but it adds a nice subtle glitter to my pencil liners.
Verdict: Keep

Smashbox Muse Cream Eye Liner Artist Pencils in Antique Gold, Slate, Lapis, and Imperial – Again, this is from the Smashbox Spring 2009 collection.  I love these pencils.  They’re not waterproof, but they blend and smudge beautifully.  My favorite is Slate.
Verdict: Keep

MUFE Aqua Eyes in 0L – I think I’ve used this once.  It supposedly stays on the waterline if you put 3 layers of it, but I haven’t tried it yet.  It’s not as creamy as my UD ones.  It actually started to shrink into the wood part because I didn’t use it for so long. :P  However, I’m almost done with my last travel sized UD Zero and I’m on my full size Zero, so I should probably keep this around.
Verdict: Keep

Too Faced Foiled Liner in Metallic Mermaid – This is almost an exact color dupe for UD’s Covet.  I don’t think I can justify having two, but Covet is a mini size and I’ve used it quite a bit, so… Also, this is worrying. :S
Verdict: Maybe/Toss

Tarte emphasEYES Inner Rim eyeliner – This came in the 500-point perk.  It kind of sucks.  I can barely get it to show up on the back of my hand, so I imagine I’d have to press really hard to get it to show on my inner rim.  Ouch.
Verdict: Toss

Cargo eyeliner in Khaki – Gorgeous color.  The cap got stuck on the bottom end of the pencil and I was worried I’d have to find some way to cover it, or throw it out, but I eventually got it unstuck.  Yay!
Verdict: Keep

Revlon ColorStay eyeliner in Navy – I bought this after I finished my first Project 10 pan.  Total impulse buy.  I’ve only used it a few times.  It’s okay.  I’m going to give it away, though.
Verdict: Give Away

Lancome Le Crayon in Khôl in Black – I think this was a 100 point sample thing from Sephora?  I don’t use it.
Verdict: Give Away

Sephora Collection Nano eyeliner in 11 Silver Green – This was Sephora birthday gift a few years back.  It’s a pretty color.  It doesn’t really fit in my UD Grindhouse sharpener, though!  I even bought another one from Sephora and that one doesn’t fit either.  I really have to force it to sharpen it.  Annoying.
Verdict: Keep

Urban Decay 24/7 eyeliners – Okay, I have a lot of these.  Mini, travel sized, full sized, you name it.  I have: Lucky, Crash, 1999, Covet, Yeyo, Gunmetal, Lust, Underground, El Dorado, Zero, Graffiti, Oil Slick, Mildew, Asphyxia, Uzi, Binge, Rockstar, Electric, Stash, Midnight Cowboy, Stray Dog, Ransom, Bourbon, Baked, Corrupt, another Zero, Perversion, Deviant, and Flipside.  And I ain’t letting any of them go.
Verdict: Keep

Physician’s Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Day & Night Lash Boosting Eyeliner Plus Serum – CHRIST, what a long name.  It’s a good black liquid eyeliner, and I like it.
Verdict: Keep

I love most of my eyeliners and I’m unwilling to part with them.  Oh well.